InsightsCase Highlights

The recent decision in Re Estate of Lo Kit [2026] HKCFI 6210 illustrates when the Court will appoint independent administrators pendente lite (“APL”) and ad colligenda bona (“ACB”) over the objection of the executrix named in a will under challenge. Deputy High Court Judge Kent Yee held that where the executrix’s authority is itself the subject of the dispute, and the parties are locked in intense hostility, she should not continue to administer the estate.

Factual & Procedural Background

The Deceased was a successful investor who died in April 2024, aged 89. His sizeable estate includes residential and commercial properties in Hong Kong, Canada and Mainland China, as well as substantial cash and stocks. In Hong Kong alone, he was the sole registered owner of eight real properties.

The Deceased allegedly made four wills. His 1983 Will, made in Canada, left his residuary estate to his first wife and their three sons in equal shares. His 2001 and 2015 Wills appointed his daughter from his second marriage (the “Defendant”) as sole executrix and sole beneficiary of his Hong Kong residuary estate. His 2023 Will, executed some four months after a stroke, appointed the Defendant as sole executrix and sole beneficiary of his global residuary estate.

In September 2025, two of the sons (the “Plaintiffs”) commenced a probate action challenging the 2023 Will. The Plaintiffs applied for (i) a proprietary injunction or preservation order, (ii) the appointment of independent administrators as APL and ACB, and (iii) ancillary disclosure. The Sister gave undertakings largely in the terms of the injunction sought, so the substantive hearing concerned only the appointment.

At the hearing concerning the appointment of APL and ACB, the Sister’s counsel argued that no appointment was necessary at all, contending, among other things, that as executrix she had pre-grant powers and had been managing the estate, relying on obiter in Re Ho Wai Man [2006] 4 HKLRD 421.

The Decision

The Court accepted the Plaintiffs’ submissions, and appointed their nominees, two partners of Deloitte, as APL and ACB. The Judge found that the appointment was necessary and expedient on the evidence. It held that the friction and hostility evident on the pleadings and affirmations meant neither side could trust the other. Continued administration by the Defendant would inevitably breed conflict and further litigation, and likely cause loss to the estate (§69).

The Defendant relied on the obiter in Re Ho Wai Man that a willing and competent local executor leaves little need for an ACB. The Court rejected this submission, holding that the core issue in the action was precisely the validity of the 2023 Will, and hence her appointment as executrix. In other words, her authority was “in hot dispute” (§64). The Court further pointed out that the question was not whether the Defendant could act before grant, but whether it was necessary or expedient to appoint someone else pending trial (§66). It concluded that the Defendant should not administer the estate, either as executrix or as APL/ACB (§70).

The Court also considered that the Hong Kong properties plainly required maintenance and upkeep, and should be let out rather than left vacant. Keeping them in repair and letting to good tenants is laborious, more so amid litigation, and independent professionals are best placed to maximise the estate’s income (§§55-56). The size of the estate and the risk of loss from mismanagement justified the cost (§74).

Key Takeaway

This case is a reminder to practitioners that the appointment of an APL or ACB is a separate question from the underlying probate dispute. The Court does not ask who is likely to win at trial. It asks whether the estate needs independent protection in the meantime. That said, appointment is not a matter of course: the Court must be independently satisfied on the evidence.

A named executrix’s pre-grant powers, and the relation-back doctrine, are beside the point where the will appointing her is itself challenged. The question is necessity or expediency, not entitlement.

It follows that an APL application should not be fought as a mini-trial on the merits. Nor will a named executor’s pre-grant powers carry much weight where the appointment is the very issue for trial. In this case, the Court considered the “resistance put up by the [Defendant]” to be “unreasonable and excessive” (§88). This is a timely reminder to parties and practitioners alike.

 

Read the full judgment here: https://legalref.judiciary.hk/lrs/common/ju/ju_frame.jsp?DIS=187115&currpage=T

 

Mr Kerby Lau and Mr Paul Law (instructed by Hugill & Ip) for the Plaintiffs.

Contact DVC

Des Voeux Chambers ("DVC") is a leading set of chambers in Hong Kong with an illustrious history dating back over 30 years. Its members have cultivated a reputation for combining intellectual rigour with effective advocacy. As one of the largest sets of chambers in Hong Kong, DVC is home to over 90 astute legal minds, many of whom have spearheaded groundbreaking cases.

General

+852 2526 3071
+852 2810 5287 (fax)

Business Hours

M – Fr  8:30 am – 7:00 pm
Sat  9:00 am – 1:00 pm

Arrangements can be made for out of office hours deliveries.

Hong Kong Office

38th Floor, Gloucester Tower
The Landmark, Central, Hong Kong

Shenzhen Office

Rm 1601, 16/F, Tower 1
Chang Fu Center (CFC)
2 Shihua Road, Futian District
Shenzhen, China